New Jersey Mat Chat

085: Sonny DiMatteo

October 7, 2026·44 min
Episode Description from the Publisher

Three high schools.Three very different experiences.And Sonny DiMatteo says he wouldn't change the path.The Point Pleasant Borough senior has already experienced more change during his high school wrestling career than most athletes ever will.He started at Brick Memorial — the program he had dreamed about wrestling for since elementary school.As a freshman, he reached the blood round in Atlantic City.As a sophomore, he placed 4th in New Jersey.Then he made a major decision.He transferred to CBA.One year later, he made another one.He left CBA and transferred to Point Pleasant Borough for his senior season.In this episode of New Jersey Mat Chat, Sonny gives an honest look at what went into those decisions and what he's learned along the way.One of the most interesting things about Sonny's story is that he doesn't pretend every decision worked exactly the way he expected.CBA wasn't ultimately the right fit.His wrestling career hasn't followed a straight line.There were losses.There were moments he questioned wrestling.There were transfers.But when we asked Sonny what he would change if he could do it all again, his answer was basically:Nothing.Brick Memorial.CBA.Point Pleasant Borough.That's the path that got him here.And as Sonny says in this episode:“Everything happens for a reason.”Now there's one chapter left.🤼 Sonny DiMatteo🏫 Point Pleasant Borough🥉 NJ State 4th Place🎟️ 3X NJ State Tournament Competitor🔥 Shore Thing WrestlingSubscribe to New Jersey Mat Chat for conversations with the wrestlers, coaches and legends shaping New Jersey wrestling.Watch 'The Godfather of MMA' Now available now on Amazon Prime:https://www.amazon.com/gp/video/detail/B0HHCGGT6S00:00 The Godfather of MMA01:06 Meet Sonny DiMatteo01:41 Growing Up at Shore Thing Wrestling03:03 Why Sonny Took a Holdback Year05:33 Why He Always Wanted to Wrestle at Brick Memorial07:55 Creating His Own Wrestling Season09:52 Why Sonny Never Bounced Between Wrestling Clubs13:04 His Freshman & Sophomore Years at Brick Memorial13:34 Why Sonny Left Brick Memorial for CBA16:57 Adjusting to Life at CBA20:12 A Rocky Start to His Junior Wrestling Season21:23 The Time Sonny Almost Quit Wrestling22:18 Why March Matters More Than Your Record23:25 Looking Back at His First Season at CBA25:23 Why Sonny Left CBA for Point Pleasant Borough26:31 Choosing to Wrestle With His Brother28:07 Starting Over at a Third High School29:17 Becoming a Leader at Point Borough30:33 Point Borough’s Team Goals32:14 Sonny’s College Wrestling Recruitment35:04 His Goals for His Senior Season36:08 Why Sonny Signed Up for a Marathon37:54 Advice to His 7-Year-Old Self38:37 Public vs. Non-Public: What Sonny Learned40:56 Why He Loves the Small-Town Feel41:48 Would He Change His High School Path?42:21 Greatest NJ High School Wrestler Ever?42:59 Why Wrestling History Matters44:15 New Jersey Mat Chat Outro

Podzilla Summary coming soon

Sign up to get notified when the full AI-powered summary is ready.

Get Free Summaries →

Free forever for up to 3 podcasts. No credit card required.

Listen to This Episode

Get summaries like this every morning.

Free AI-powered recaps of New Jersey Mat Chat and your other favorite podcasts, delivered to your inbox.

Get Free Summaries →

Free forever for up to 3 podcasts. No credit card required.